Medicare Supplement Leads Now…

If you run a lead company selling Medicare Supplement leads, your business would be totally dependent upon your customers doing one thing… buying more leads.

I think of lead companies a little bit like pushers. If they can get you hooked and give you just enough information to make a few sales, you will make the sales, get your commission and keep coming back for more.

The fact is however that a large percentage of leads you buy will NEVER answer their phone or email. They fill out a form (or more likely, several forms) online and within minutes, their phone is ringing like crazy and their email is jammed with sales messages from hungry sales people. Our numbers indicate that about 60% of the leads we buy will collect just enough information and then go straight to the company of their choice.

I am going to reveal 3 little secrets that allowed us to capture about 30% of the leads that were falling in to the lead black hole. You should be warned, if you are looking for a “quick fix,” this is not it. Many of these leads take a year or more to convert to sales, but if you can convert these leads, your return on your investment will skyrocket.

1. You MUST Build Trust With Your Prospect Before They Will Ever Buy from You

Most of our prospects for Medicare Supplement insurance are going online because they want to buy their insurance without the hassle of having to talk to some insurance agent. The ironic thing is however, they don’t trust the internet. The web is fine for information, and it is OK to buy a crock pot from a big trusted store like Amazon, but other than that, people know that the web is full of scammers. If you call them from the web, they don’t trust you. Period.

So, how do you build their trust? The first thing to do is show them that you are a true human being. The first thing we do after we get a lead that doesn’t respond, we send them a hand-written thank you card with a picture of our staff. If you don’t have a staff, then send them a picture of your family.

Why? You need to let them see that you are the real deal, not some “internet shadow” hiding behind the building, waiting to rip em off.

After we send em a real card, we send em an e-card in about two weeks, from a legitimate e-card company. There are several good ones. We like Blue Mountain, because they are cheap and easy to use.

The next thing we do is send them an e-card about once a month. But here is the trick. Don’t EVER mention insurance. Send them a “funny” card, or holiday card. Again, the idea is to let them see that you are a real human.

By about the second or third month, you will be amazed at how many people are still in their open enrollment, who begin to call you and say, “Thanks for all the cards. I’ve been meaning to call you…”

2. You MUST Be Persistent. Persistence Pays

Most agents lose most of their sales for lack of one thing… persistence. I don’t mean pesky, in your face, high pressure sales kind of persistence (those days are gone forever, get over it). I simply mean, staying in front of someone long enough for them to get to know and trust you.

Every lead we get, we “assume the sale.” Not necessarily in the first week, or even the first couple of months. But, we never throw away a lead until essentially, that person says, “go away, you are bothering me.” Even when someone says that, we don’t give up. We send them a final, paper card that says, “I am sorry I bothered you, if you ever need my services in the future, I am here for you.”

3. You MUST Use Technology and Forget About the Kitchen Table

Unless you already know them, baby boomers don’t want you coming to their house. There are a couple of ways around this.

A. Rent a cheap office. Did you know you can get a very nice, executive (even penthouse) office for about $30 per month. Companies like Regus allow you to buy what is called a “mail account” which gives you access to two things. 1) A real mailing address and 2) Access to rent an executive suite by the hour or day (for very reasonable rates). If you can get clients to come to your office, it makes you look professional and you become a “trusted advisor” rather than some schmuck salesman.

B. Get a website. Forget about building a big website and driving thousands of visitors to your site. Unless you are willing to invest about $50,000 in time and education to learn how to effectively do this, you might as well forget it. Insurance is one of the most competitive niches on the web. There are big companies with big dollars invested on the web. You will not compete with them.

The good news is, you don’t need to compete with them. Did you know that studies have shown that in online marketing, small websites actually “convert” better than big fancy websites. Why? I don’t know. I suppose it goes back to the trust factor. If people think you are just another one of those “internet shadows,” they will probably avoid you. This is not to say, you should get a cheesy, ugly website. To learn more about this, read my article on medicare lead generation and branding you!

So there you have it, three little secrets the drug, er, the lead companies don’t want you to know. Go forth, be patient, be persistent, build your business and stop supporting those pushers.